thats a hard one, saltwater is newer to me and therefore more exciting but I've grown up fishing fresh and have more tricks for it, right now its fresh but that ...more might change as i get more familiar
@theyakfisher @LivewellHero @colby12 @wyldechylde77 I'm allergic to fish so I can't tell you which is better but I've got to say sunfish are one beautiful ...more fish even more so when it's sticking out of
Yellow Perch tastes much better than Sunfish any day, no matter how it's cooked (with the exception of Crappie; close call!). Perch are like the poor man's ...more Walleye haha. Battle-wise? Sunnies all day!
Carp all day out fight any thing I have ever hooked also if you think that carp are "killing your fishery" you need to open your eyes they have been here ...more longer than brown trout or rainbows in the eas
I catch both here (+ tiger musky) in WNY, and can tell you that there isn't much difference between the two. Muskie are a little tougher to locate, but both ...more put up vicious fights. Toss up here.
Obviously musky are the "trophy fish" out of these two. I think pike are cool 4 the sheer # you can catch in a single outting. plus they are DELICIOUS!! ...more I've never caught a musky so.. I VOTE MUSKY