Buffalo Lake

Marquette - Wisconsin


  • 20 catches

  • 192 followers

  • 7 spots

Because of the shallow water here, topwater lures are popular when the weeds thicken in summer. Quality panfish are aggressive year-round.

Premium Mapping

Find Local Fishing Spots on the Interactive Map!

Already have an account? Sign in

or
*Used to locate nearby fishing activity


By signing up with Fishidy you accept the User Terms and Privacy Policy.

Buffalo Lake Fishing Reports

Recently shared catches and fishing spots

  1. Mike Fitzgerald
    - Buffalo Lake

    4 lb. 2 oz. 21 in. Largemouth Bass with a Neko worm

    1. Mike Fitzgerald 0
      it’s a Great Lake. lotta bass, pike and panfish. gets weedy in the summer but the cutters do a great job. I’ve been coming here for about 30 years and owned a home ...more for 12. it’s relatively quit considering the size. oh yeah I’m on Buffalo, there’s also Montello lake
    2. Mike Fitzgerald 0
      it’s a Great Lake. lotta bass, pike and panfish. gets weedy in the summer but the cutters do a great job. I’ve been coming here for about 30 years and owned a home ...more for 12. it’s relatively quit considering the size. oh yeah I’m on Buffalo, there’s also Montello lake
    3. Vincent Cotter 0
      damn nice bass. how's this lake? was looking into pipedream of owning lakefront property in Montello Wisconsin area. thanks tight lines
    4. View full conversation
  2. Steve Isberner
    - Buffalo Lake

    Details: Pan fish

  3. Steve Wendt
    - Buffalo Lake

    Hard to complain, eaters and a top 10 movie!😂

    11.0 in. Black Crappie

    1. Ray Bied 0
      Nice going Steve!
    2. Jeff Carter 0
      Nice!
    3. View full conversation
  4. Mike Fitzgerald
    - Buffalo Lake

    18 in. Largemouth Bass with a Strike King Standard Buzzbaits

    1. Jeff Carter 0
      Nice fish!
  5. Steve Wendt
    - Buffalo Lake

    Smallmouth Bass

    1. Ray Bied 0
      Nice going Steve!
  6. Russell Syens
    - Buffalo Lake

    27 in. Northern Pike

    1. jeff bennett 0
      Nice
  7. Clayton Broesch
    - Buffalo Lake

    16 in. Smallmouth Bass with a jig and tube

  8. Clayton Broesch
    - Buffalo Lake

    caught this from the shore at night time.

    19 in. Smallmouth Bass

    1. Ray Bied 0
      Terrific!!! Good Job!!
  9. Torry Harbecke
    - Buffalo Lake

    My son caught about 30 of these nothing worth keeping but he had a blast!

    2 oz. 5 in. Bluegill with a worm

    1. Brandon Wilkes 0
      Nice one
    2. Ray Bied 0
      That's great! Your boy will grow into a fine young man.
    3. View full conversation
  10. Dan glaser
    - Buffalo Lake

    trolling

    Walleye with a sr5

    1. Ray Bied 0
      Okay. Thanks Dan.
    2. Ray Bied 0
      Okay. Thanks Dan.
    3. Dan glaser 0
      most certainly buffalo..i live on it..and fish puck regular too but for buff it takes lots of improvising lol..... keep boards close usually one long line one board ...more out 40 n only certain sectipns of the channel obvi rest of the lake is choked with weeds so its tricky but possible...the live baiy trollin is better when weesa are too heavy but chnnel remains hard sand in many areas expensive sonar willhelp or just from fiahing the lake ALOT..Ive foshed buffalo sinve i was a kid n its obe of the hardest waters to get quality fish..if ya have any questions feel free to pm me.
    4. Ray Bied 0
      How can you troll in all that much? You sure you don't mean Puckaway?
    5. Dan glaser 0
      is that a serious question? Walleyes have always been in Buffalo since the fish ladder now there is a decent population special way to fish for them though very ...more tricky Lake
    6. Ray Bied 0
      When was the last time walleyes were in Buffalo?
    7. View full conversation

Find more fishing reports in Wisconsin

  • Williams Lake

    Williams Lake is a 54 acre lake located in Marquette County. It has a maximum depth of 6 feet. Visitors have access to the lake from a public boat landing. Fish include Panfish, Largemouth Bass and No...

    Followers
    15
    Catches
    1
    Spots
    1
  • Lake Emery

    Lake Emery is a 32 acre waterway in Marquette County, Wisconsin. It has a maximum depth of 12 feet. Panfish, Largemouth Bass, Northern Pike and Trout can be found here. Visitors have access to Lake Em...

    Followers
    6
    Catches
    0
    Spots
    0
  • Metcalf Lake

    Metcalf Lake is a 26 acre waterway in Marquette County, Wisconsin. It has a maximum depth of 31 feet. Panfish, Largemouth Bass and Northern Pike can be found here. The water clarity is .

    Followers
    5
    Catches
    0
    Spots
    0
  • Big Pine Lake

    Big Pine Lake is a 5 acre waterway in Marquette County, Wisconsin. It has a maximum depth of 12 feet. Panfish and Largemouth Bass can be found here. The water clarity is .

    Followers
    5
    Catches
    0
    Spots
    0
Loading...