Pymatuning Lake

Crawford - Pennsylvania

  • 149 catches

  • 1K+ followers

  • 91 spots

Extremely popular lake known primarily for Walleye and Crappie. Many overlook the fine largemouth and smallmouth fishing. Heavy management and stocking on this OH/PA border water. 13,699 acres

Find Local Fishing Spots on the Interactive Map!

*Used to locate nearby fishing activity

By signing up with Fishidy you accept the User Terms and Privacy Policy.

Pymatuning Lake Fishing Reports

Recently shared catches and fishing spots

  1. 40 in. muskie with a medussa

    1. Daniel Lutton
      I would recommend around stocker & beer can island I concentrated on water between 10 & 12 ft hope this helps find the baitfish you will find the muskie
    2. Jim Mortell
      Nice catch. We are fishing at Pymatuning for Musky next weekend...Any suggestions?
    3. View full conversation
  2. Only got out for a quick evening trip in the wind. Managed one little guy before we lost the light.

    Smallmouth Bass with a Strike King 5XD

  3. channel cat

    7 lb. 4 oz. 27 in. Channel Catfish with a hotdog

  4. Details: 19 in. Channel Catfish? with a floating jig

    released for someone else to catch.

  5. Details: 17 in. Walleye with a crawlers


    1. Jim Mortell
      Hi Wes . I have talked to some fisherman at Pymatuning Lake that told me they were catching some Walleye suspended. Was your catch like this or on the bootom? ...more We fish Jamestown area
  6. 2 lb. catfish with a lindy rig

    1. Dudley R
      Not as much as it used to be. fished off the shore and caught only this, a few smallmouth and some perch.
    2. Charles Mccreary
      Does anybody catch walleye there anymore
    3. View full conversation
  7. Under the causeway

    Black Crappie with a crappie magic jigs

    1. Eddie Green and wife went 715-17 fish at pymatuning couldn't get under bridge people were there d not catch anything
    2. Brian Brown
      On shore.
    3. Eddie Green
      were you in a boat or on shore?
    4. View full conversation
  8. 2 lb. 2 oz. Largemouth Bass with a grub

  9. Details: Rock Wall

    I don't really see any visible cover except the wall itself, yet it produces greatly for me when fishing off the bottom in deep water using a worm from the rock ...more wall.

    1. Dominic Scotillo
      Within 2 miles of Beach #2 and Richter's Bait & Tackle, I'm pretty sure its by the dam
    2. Jim Mortell
      Near the spillway , Causeway or the dam?
    3. View full conversation
  10. 1 of 4 largemouth, bluegills, and channel cats.

    1. Joe K.
      caught using a topwater rapala.

Find more fishing reports in Pennsylvania

  • Mosquito Lake

    Mosquito Lake is one of the largest lakes in Ohio, and its many recreational opportunities attract both fishermen and pleasure boaters. Mosquito Lake State Park provides excellent camping and day-use...


  • Lake Wilhelm

    An outstanding warmwater fishery supports quality Largemouth Bass, black Crappie and Bluegill. The bass maintain one of the most dense and stable populations in the state. Good numbers of purebred m...


  • Lake Erie

    Lake Erie is the fourth largest lake (by surface area) of the five Great Lakes in North America, and the tenth largest globally] or twelfth largest globally if measured in terms of surface area.It is ...


  • Shenango Lake

    Crappie are by far the most popular species. The typical fish runs 10 to 12 inches with plenty of 14-to 16-inch slabs available. Largemouth numbers are good. Shenango is also one of PA's premier Chann...