Butterfield Lake

Jefferson - New York


  • 5 catches

  • 151 followers

  • 1 spots

Butterfield Lake is known for its nice largemouth bass and crappies but there are also nice, stocked walleye, fair smallmouth bass, nice perch, and even a few channel catfish swimming around. If you are interested in catching these fish then you should tr...

Find Local Fishing Spots on the Interactive Map!

Already have an account? Sign in

or
*Used to locate nearby fishing activity


By signing up with Fishidy you accept the User Terms and Privacy Policy.

Butterfield Lake Fishing Reports

Recently shared catches and fishing spots

  1. Jamie Besaw
    - Butterfield Lake

    4 lb. 9 oz. 20 in. Largemouth Bass with a drop shot

  2. Jamie Besaw
    - Butterfield Lake

    they told me they were in here but this is the first smallie I've got out of this lake. didn't measure or weigh it. probably 2-2.5lbs.

    Smallmouth Bass with a medium diving crankbait in a bluegill pattern

  3. Chris Bidwell
    - Butterfield Lake

    Details: perch hot 2-10-18

  4. Jason Rotolo
    - Butterfield Lake

    5 oz. 6 in. Smallmouth Bass with a drop shot/worm

    1. Dillen Kangas 0
      That's a crappie
    2. Jason Rotolo 0
      lol
    3. View full conversation
  5. Mike Bean
    - Butterfield Lake

    Couple Slobs

    12 in. Crappie with a jig

  6. Brad Paradis
    - Butterfield Lake

    5 lb largemouth

    Largemouth Bass with a jig n pig

    1. Lunker McLaker (aka T.O.) 0
      awesome largemouth!!
    2. Rich Pardy 0
      Another brute, nice!!
    3. Tim Cote 0
      Nice fish
    4. View full conversation

Find more fishing reports in New York

  • Black Lake

    Black Lake’s shallow, fertile waters support one of the finest warmwater sport fisheries in New York, but one that has experienced sweeping changes in the past 25 years.

    Followers
    799
    Catches
    114
    Spots
    132
  • Red Lake

    If you like pike that average 8lbs, largemouth bass that average 3lbs, smallmouth bass that average 2lbs, walleye that also average 2lbs, a few nice channel catfish, and panfish that average about .8-...

    Followers
    115
    Catches
    16
    Spots
    4
  • Hyde Lake

    Hyde Lake is a good lake to fish just for the fact the lake gets almost no boating pressure. Not to mention the fact that Hyde Lake contains two fish most of the lakes in the area don’t, tiger muskies...

    Followers
    99
    Catches
    6
    Spots
    0
  • Moon Lake

    10 horsepower limit

    Followers
    86
    Catches
    3
    Spots
    1
Loading...