Allegheny Reservoir

Cattaraugus - New York


  • 94 catches

  • 338 followers

  • 26 spots

While the primary purpose of this reservoir is flood control, the water supports a trophy fishery. Walleye draws over 75% of the angler interest. Both the New York and Pennsylvania records come from this border water (16 pounds, 8 ounces.) Also smallmouth...

Premium Mapping

Find Local Fishing Spots on the Interactive Map!

Already have an account? Sign in

or
*Used to locate nearby fishing activity


By signing up with Fishidy you accept the User Terms and Privacy Policy.

Allegheny Reservoir Fishing Reports

Recently shared catches and fishing spots

  1. Rob O
    - Allegheny Reservoir

    Went to the Kinzua reservoir for a walleye tournament and got this bonus fish . Thought it was a lunker eye . Turned out to be a picture fish . But did win the tournament!!!! ...more Great weekend

    42 in. Northern Pike with a Silver Buddy Blade Bait

    1. Rick S 0
      Beautiful Northern! Congrats on tournament win!
  2. Alexander Nye
    - Allegheny Reservoir

    Texas rigged Senko was Pumpkin-Black and Green

    Smallmouth Bass with a Gary Yamamoto Original Senko Worms

  3. Jack Soles
    - Allegheny Reservoir

    40" 35 lbs. 5/28/2020 10AM

    35 lb. 40 in. Tiger Muskellunge with a Green Yozuri Lure

    1. Jaydin Pratt 0
      love it!
    2. Jaydin Pratt 0
      love it
    3. Capt Morris Campbell 0
      wow
    4. Matt Cavallo 0
      Nice catch!
    5. View full conversation
  4. Lanny Vrooman
    - Allegheny Reservoir

    Details: 6 in. Yellow Perch with a nightcrawler

  5. Lanny Vrooman
    - Allegheny Reservoir

    Details: 7 in. Smallmouth Bass with a nightcrawler

  6. Lanny Vrooman
    - Allegheny Reservoir

    Details: 14 in. Walleye with a nightcrawler

  7. Lanny Vrooman
    - Allegheny Reservoir

    Details: 12 in. Walleye with a nightcrawler

  8. Derek Stitt
    - Allegheny Reservoir

    Smallmouth Bass

    1. Derek Stitt 0
      Thanks everybody 👍👊
    2. Wade Bowles 0
      Nice pair Derek
    3. Shawn Gearinger 0
      That's a pare of beauties!!👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻🎣🎣
    4. Melissa Norris 0
      very nice 😀
    5. Christopher Pereira 0
      Bicep curls!
    6. Arthur Huttemeyer Sr. 0
      Nice double
    7. Robert Coleman 0
      Now THAT'S a nice pair of Bronzebacks! 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
    8. Bryan Harper 0
      Chunks!🎣🎣
    9. john stimson 0
      oh , that is how its done , nice pair
    10. Josh Sommerville 0
      Good pair of Smallies Derek👊🏻
    11. Capt Morris Campbell 0
      nice bookends Derek!!!👍
    12. View full conversation
  9. jason greeley
    - Allegheny Reservoir

    2 lb. 16 in. Smallmouth Bass with a 4" Storm 360GT searchbait in Pearl Ice color

  10. malarikfishing malarikfishing
    - Allegheny Reservoir

    Smallmouth Bass with a chigger craw

Find more fishing reports in New York

  • Chautauqua Lake

    Chautauqua Lake offers an incredibly diverse fishing resource - and one that continues to change, including the discovery of zebra mussels. The high fertility, weed cover, size and relatively shallow ...

    Followers
    892
    Catches
    314
    Spots
    298
  • Allegheny River (Kinzua Dam Tailrace)

    Walleye, northern pike. Kinzua Dam tailrace on St. Rt. 59, six miles from Warren. Ample parking. Live bait available in Warren. Rapalas will take fish. Open water. Also try for Northern Pike at the m...

    Followers
    425
    Catches
    21
    Spots
    3
  • Quaker Lake

    5 horsepower electric morots only

    Followers
    80
    Catches
    6
    Spots
    4
  • Red House Lake

    No motors

    Followers
    75
    Catches
    6
    Spots
    1
Loading...