Cagles Mill Lake

Putnam - Indiana


  • 22 catches

  • 363 followers

  • 3 spots

The Cagles Mill Lake is located in Putnam County, Indiana and is part of the Lieber State Park. It is also known as Cataract Lake due to its proximity to the nearby town of the same name.

Find Local Fishing Spots on the Interactive Map!

Already have an account? Sign in

or
*Used to locate nearby fishing activity


By signing up with Fishidy you accept the User Terms and Privacy Policy.

Cagles Mill Lake Fishing Reports

Recently shared catches and fishing spots

  1. 6 lbs

    Smallmouth Bass with a Creek Chub Jointed Pikie

  2. 3 nice pre spawn walleye.

    26.0 in. Walleye with a B Fish N Tackle AuthentX Pulse-R Paddle Tail

    1. fish sober 0
      was draggin with some snaps
    2. wow very nice I haven't been to cagle's mill this year do to medical problems
    3. fish sober 0
      I've seen willow pine and right at dark
    4. J C 0
      check out willowpine outdoors and crossroads walleye!
    5. J C 0
      did u catch them at night?
    6. J C 0
      did u catch them at night?
    7. J C 0
      did u catch them at night?
    8. very nice
    9. Fred Phelps 0
      Nice fish were you casting or trolling?
    10. Griffin Lenz 0
      Nice! Fish look super healthy.
    11. fish sober 0
      no lake side off rocks near a drop off
    12. Griffin Lenz 0
      was this tail water?
    13. Awesome
    14. Charles Spiker 0
      nice!
    15. View full conversation
  3. Crappie kinda day out on cataract. No walleyes today.

    White Crappie with a Berkley Blank Flicker Shad Crankbait

    1. Scott Sorrell 0
      Nice one
    2. J C 0
      do you catch any walleyes on the lake?
    3. View full conversation
  4. location is close-ish. im not the navigator, and it was dark. 15 lb bluecat is what I was told, looked channel-ish to me, but i don't catfish ... i stalk the ...more bass,.....poorly.
    bout 3 a.m. small gizzard shad, on bottom, spinning outfit with a 6.5 medium action tip broken off rod with new 8 lb. mono. released to fight another day,

    Blue Catfish with a gizzard shad

  5. 6 lb. 29 in. Walleye with a Cotton Cordell Wally Diver

    1. fish sober 0
      pretty high
    2. Les Smith 0
      Beautiful eye! How high is the lake?
    3. Aldo Rosado 0
      What I love about fishing is that it's like a box of Cracker Jacks, it's like opening Christmas presents, it's like your birthday opening presents, when ...more you fish you wonder what you will get and some times to your surprise it's a big gift and you smile and take a pic of your catch put it on line and share it and I smile with you man!. Nice Fish
    4. View full conversation
  6. trolled for walleye. only caught a couple walleye, non big enough to keep. and caught a couple nice crappie while trolling. deep diving cranks

    13 in. Walleye

    1. J C 0
      Have you been back since?
    2. Fen Wick 0
      it's a good way to locate fish.
    3. Jeremiah Wattigny 0
      I been thanking about getting into trolling
    4. Fen Wick 0
      our crankbaits went about 8 to 10 feet deep. we trolled back and forth over a hump that went from like 17 feet up to 6 feet
    5. Jeremiah Wattigny 0
      How deep you trolling?
    6. View full conversation
  7. anyone hooked any walleye out here lately

Find more fishing reports in Indiana


  • Monroe Lake

    Indiana's largest lake and home to a trophy bass fishery. Crappie are abundant and attract a lot of attention. A quality catfish population is widely ignored. 10,750 acres A section of the Monroe Lake...

    Followers
    1372
    Catches
    166
    Spots
    88

  • Lake Waveland

    Lake Waveland is an excellent fishery with excellent structure along the shore line. It is a popular tournament spot.

    Followers
    253
    Catches
    9
    Spots
    3

  • Griffy Lake

    Griffy Lake is a water reservoir in the city of Bloomington, Indiana. Created by a dam on Griffy Creek in the 1920s, the reservoir used to serve as the main source of drinking water for Bloomington fo...

    Followers
    240
    Catches
    6
    Spots
    1

  • Yellowwood Lake

    Yellowwood Lake is a 133 acre lake located in Brown county. The maximum depth is 29 feet.

    Followers
    220
    Catches
    9
    Spots
    17

Loading...